21 January 2009

Book Review: I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have To Kill You

Quick Stats
Genre - YA
Length - ~280pages
Author - Ally Carter

Cammie Morgan looks like she goes to a private school for rich, snobby girls. What the school actually is is the Gallagher Academy, a spy-training school for girl geniuses. Her sophomore year at the school (yes, this is book one) seems to be going well - but even their new class, Covert Operations, doesn't teach her what she needs to know: how to speak Boy. Especially when said boy is sweet, funny, good-looking - and normal. Normal's the last thing Cammie is...

First Impressions
Absolutely fabulous. Like a really good YA, the scene is set quickly, the voice develops strongly, and the plot Starts Happening.

High Points
For starters, the whole premise. Yes, I admit, I'm wildly into secret and spies and assassins and societies and whatnot, so the idea of a secret spy school that trains girls only, and poses as a posh boarding school is tremendously exciting.

The voice is great, there's plenty of tension, and the ending isn't quite predictable. There's a great balance of 'real' teenageness and adult story-telling. I also adore the fact that this book is completely clean - no language, nothing worthy of more than a PG rating. For those of you that must know such things, the 'smush' is pretty much behind curtain.

Which is another thing I adore about this book: it's from the POV of a teenage girl, AND it avoids sappy romance and unrealistic portrayals of relationships. Those of you that know me well know that an absolutely HUGE pet peeve of mine is the unrealistic relationships that so much of the media portrays, aimed at teenage girls with their susceptability to sap (yes, myself included when I was a teen). It just breeds SO MANY ISSUES - but I won't go into that here. And just for the record, I've nothing against romance.

Low Points
None, really - but it is a quick, light-hearted read, so if you need more meat in your stories this might not be for you. It's not dark or edgy :) It's also very definitely YA, so if you need stories with subplots, multi-POVs, and tangled, complex storylines, this isn't your thing.

If I was doing stars, it would have 5. As it is, I'd Tell You I Love You, But Then I'd Have To Kill You gets to be a pocket book - one that you carry around in your pocket until you finish it, because it's just. that. good. Mind, mine never went into my pocket, as I read it in one sitting, but yes O:)


marieconley3 said...

We miss you!

And it sounds like a good book!

Lady Glamis said...

I miss you, too, Inky.

*cries and sobs*

I read a review on this book on somebody else's blog, too. It looks good!

Yunaleska said...

Sounds great! Hope we have it in the UK...

Inkblot said...

Yeah, I was excited to learn that we have it here in Aus :) Great book, much fun.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...